Guest
CommentaryWyatt Emmerich publisher of the Northside Sun and president of Emmerich Newspapers. |
Hollywood's portrayal
of the American business system as greedy, cutthroat and mercenary has done
tremendous harm to our country. So it was great to hear famous author George
Gilder speaking in Jackson to a group at the Wesleyan Biblical Seminary. He
proclaimed this perverted world view to be outright false.
Gilder's book Wealth & Poverty has sold over a million copies. Some credit Gilder
as the ideological founder of welfare reform, which has enabled millions to
get off welfare and join the work force.
Lately, his books have focused on technology and the future. He is considered
a visionary by many leaders in the technology industry. Gilder blamed 18th century
economic philosopher Adam Smith for the view that capitalism is fueled by greed.
Adam Smith's view was that our economic system is a kind of Faustian pact in
which we accept greed and avarice in return for prosperity, Gilder told the
group of one hundred.
I think this view is fundamentally incorrect and leads to the media having a
false view of events such as WorldCom.
Greed manifests itself everywhere, in all economic systems. It's part of human
nature, not part of capitalism. In fact, the basis of greed is to acquire unearned
income while a capitalist is willing to earn his income through offering customers
what they freely choose to buy in the marketplace.
Greed could never lead to the prosperity we enjoy in America. If you are truly
greedy you want unearned income so you appeal to government which has the guns
to help you get your unearned income.
It is the desire for unearned income, rather than the results of voluntary acts
of customers, that is the foundation of greed and socialism.
Profit is in fact an index of altruism. It is the difference between the value
of the product to the producer and the value of the product to the customer.
Capitalism is based on altruism, on meeting people's needs.
Capitalism wants others to succeed because capitalism only works if your customers
have money. The largest market is the growing working class. Capitalism is a
collaborative effort. You have to collaborate with customers, investors and
suppliers.
Capitalism depends on trust and faith. It depends on making an investment without
any guarantee of a return. It also depends on the Golden Rule. If everyone tries
to cheat the system, it will collapse.
Capitalism is a redemptive force in our society and should be seen as a convergent
force with Christianity. Without morality, capitalists are forced to pander
to depraved desires and they all become pornographers and drug pushers. I have
no doubt that there are some greedy businessmen out there. Greed is part of
human nature. But the capitalistic system itself is not greedy. Most businessmen
that I know are hard-working, moral and care very much for others. Just look
at all the charitable contributions businesses make each year. Many of our organizations
could not exist but for the very ungreedy contributions coming from our businesses.
Perhaps business gets a bad rap because executives don't hand out raises, lower
prices and expand services. A lot of people want something for nothing.
Such actions would put the company out of business and the employees out of
work in short order. Running a business is a delicate balance of keeping employees,
customers, investors, bankers and suppliers happy, despite competing interests.
Capitalism is really just a fancy word describing what happens when free people
engage one another in a free marketplace. It is the natural result of freedom
and liberty. Capitalism is intrinsic in human nature.
I have to laugh when I see groups being described as "pro-business." As opposed
to what? Unemployment? Communism? Poverty?
If you are "anti-business" what does that mean? That you want commerce to cease
and for people to go back to farming 20-acre plots?
I don't think so.